Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice Mix

69 comments

pumpkinpiespicemix

For the past couple seasons, I’ve been on the hunt for pumpkin pie spice mix. And I’ve been slowly going crazy not being able to locate it in any local grocery stores. Don’t they know how many they would sell from me alone?! I longed for the day I would cross paths with it, making a mental note to buy 10 if I ever did. Only that day never came and I went about my life smiling on the outside, but secretly feeling like a piece of me was missing. Until that beloved day when a recipe just fell into my lap!

I feel like fellow bloggers and cookbook authors, Nicole Axworthy and Lisa Pitman, get me. They know that vegan staples aren’t always offered in grocery stores (yes, I just called pumpkin spice mix a “vegan staple”…let’s go with it), and sometimes we want or need to make things in our own kitchen. In their new book, DIY Vegan, you’ll find more than 100 vegan recipes showing home cooks just how easy it is to create knock-offs of common store-bought staples, only without the sometimes scary ingredient lists. For the most part, I try to limit the amount of prepared foods that I purchase due to the unpronounceable ingredients many contain. And really, these foods don’t always leave me feeling my best. Yes, more and more brands are coming out with simple, whole-foods ingredient lists (hooray), but sometimes these brands aren’t accessible or they’re just plain old expensive. So, I enjoy making my own staples when time allows; especially if I can make a huge batch and store it for several months, like with this pumpkin pie spice mix. Major kitchen win!

As Nicole and Lisa say, "Seriously, are you going to pay extra for someone else to stir your spices? We didn’t think so. Make your own in seconds, make some for your friends, start a business selling your own spice-stirring services. And then eat pie."

In DIY Vegan, you’ll find vegan recipes like Buttermilk, Cashew Coffee Creamer, Simple Sour Cream, Coconut Yogurt, Cultured Nut Cheese, Whole-Grain and Seed bread, Cheesy Crackers, Taco Seasoning, Spelt Pizza Dough, and many more. I went straight for the Pumpkin Pie Spice Mix of course, and after falling in love I made a triple batch to keep on hand. It’s just so easy and flavourful, and now I never have to go without. If you noticed that super cute jar at the top of this post, you’ll see that it also makes a fun gift for the pumpkin pie spice mix lover in your life. Just place the spices into a tiny jar (you can layer it for fun), add some baker’s twine, and loop on a homemade tag. Wouldn’t this be a cute idea for a housewarming gift or a party favour? Or maybe I’m just weird. Rest assured, if you ever brought me this I would light up like a Christmas tree.

Coming up soon, I’ll be sharing a baked good that I created using this very pumpkin pie spice mix. You don’t want to miss this one, folks. It’s the seasonal baked good I promise you’ll want to whip up all season long. So go on and make this spice mix then meet me back here for Part 2! Deal?

pumpkinpiespicemixhomemade

Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice Mix

Vegan, gluten-free, grain-free, no bake/raw, nut-free, oil-free, refined sugar-free, soy-free

By

4.8 from 11 reviews
Print

Use this pumpkin pie spice mix in cakes, cookies, bars, oatmeal, smoothies, lattes, chia seed pudding, and more! I like to keep a large batch of it on hand and I find myself using it in just about everything. This recipe is reprinted with permission from DIY Vegan. Copyright © 2015 Nicole Axworthy and Lisa Pitman. Published by St. Martin's Griffin.

Yield
2 1/2 tablespoons
Prep Time
Cook time
0 Minutes
Total Time

Ingredients:

  • 4 teaspoons cinnamon
  • 2 teaspoons ground ginger
  • 1 teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg (I pack it in the teaspoon)
  • 1 teaspoon ground allspice
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground cloves

Directions:

  1. Combine all the ingredients in an airtight container or jar. Attach lid and shake to combine. Store at room temperature for up to 6 months. Shake jar before each use.

pumpkinpiespicemix2

Photography credit: Ashley McLaughlin Photography

A big congrats to Nicole and Lisa on this beautiful cookbook, and for allowing me to share this recipe with you today! DIY Vegan is hot off the press this Tuesday, October 27th so be sure to check it out online and in bookstores!

Let's get social! Follow Angela on Instagram (@ohsheglows + @theglowspot), Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Snapchat, and Google+

Previous Posts

{ 69 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Kinsey October 25, 2015
Recipe Rating:

This is so useful; pumpkin pie spice is always so expensive at the store!

Reply

2 Laura ~ Raise Your Garden October 26, 2015

I was thinking the exact same thing! I paid 7 bucks for the tiniest bottle of pumpkin pie spice and was so frustrated! I feel like, I love trying new recipes, but spend so much on “extra” ingredients that I don’t have have on hand ~ that I don’t end up actually saving $$ by cooking at home. This is SO useful. Thanks Angela. (and easy!!!)

Reply

3 Heidi Kokborg October 25, 2015

I can’t believe how easy this pumpkin pie spice is to make! & cheap!! Can’t wait to make this and use it, oh well, everything :) Thank you so much for sharing, Angela!

Reply

4 Brynn October 25, 2015

Why have I never thought to make my own mix?! Gah! Looking forward to the recipe!

Reply

5 Brandon October 25, 2015

No cardamom on the list? It’s heavenly in pumpkin pie.

Reply

6 Angela (Oh She Glows) October 26, 2015

Feel free to tweak it as you see fit! This is Lisa and Nicole’s fav version, but by all means create your own.

Reply

7 Sandy October 26, 2015

I like the way you think!

Reply

8 Jaimee November 7, 2015

Hi can you please give a recommendation for how much cardamon to use? I don’t know how strong this is and don’t want it to overpower the other spices.

Reply

9 Lynda Kirkness November 9, 2015

I like cardamom and also want to know how much to add to the pumpkin pie spice recipe. My mom had mace in pumpkin pie and I really liked that.

Reply

10 Laura October 25, 2015
Recipe Rating:

This is what I need, in England I can’t find pumpkin pie spice mix in any shop, thank you for this !

Reply

11 Amanda - Create N Plate October 25, 2015

I can’t wait to give this a try!

Reply

12 Jennifer October 25, 2015

Can I use ground nutmeg instead of fresh? If so, would I have to use less than a tsp?

Reply

13 Sonya October 25, 2015

That’s what I used… You’d still use a tsp!

Reply

14 Angela (Oh She Glows) October 26, 2015

Glad that worked out Sonya!

Reply

15 Angela (Oh She Glows) October 26, 2015

I tend to think that ground nutmeg is a bit stronger (and more compact) than freshly grated stuff. I would probably start with half the amount and then taste and adjust from there!

Reply

16 Matea October 25, 2015

Can’t wait to make my own spice mix! Also, I think I heard allspice is a mixture of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves; is that true?

Reply

17 Kelly November 15, 2015

I think that’s “mixed spice”.
Allspice is not a mixture, it’s from a pimenta berry.

Reply

18 Erin @ Erin's Inside Job October 25, 2015

I’m actually on the fence about making my own chai spice. My husband is Indian so I’ve had some great chai when his family gets together. No tea seems to measure up and his cousin has a homemade chai masala that she adds in her black tea and it is PERFECT. I bought some at an Indian store and it’s not the same and definitely not as fresh so now I think I may have to whip up some of my own. Maybe this is a sign…. :)

Reply

19 Hillary October 26, 2015

Creeper me just read your blog post and actually thought of you while reading this one! LOL! Definitely post the recipe for the chai masala if you get it right!

Reply

20 Ashley October 25, 2015
Recipe Rating:

The inner child in me had so much fun styling the first jar shot for this post. I was definitely a sucker for sand art growing up. Also, this pumpkin pie spice is totally on point! Love that I have a big jar of it ready to go now! :)

Reply

21 Annaliese October 25, 2015

Yes! I love seasonal spices…especially right now, when the weather is cooling…I go through so much cinnamon, whole nutmegs, cloves, ginger….everything! I may have to whip up a batch of this to try it, as I am usually a believer in blending my spices to my tastes on the particular day. Thanks for the great idea :)

Reply

22 Bailey October 26, 2015

Is it super sad and naive of me to wish that there were more to this mix? Some bit of magic mixed in that cannot be created with simple spices??

Bailey |One Thousand Joys

Reply

23 Angela (Oh She Glows) October 26, 2015

pepper for a little black magic, perhaps? lol

Reply

24 Julia October 26, 2015

Hey! I am about to order the cookbook and I am wondering if the quantities are also indicated for international ? Thanks!!

Reply

25 Angela (Oh She Glows) October 26, 2015

Hi Julia, I’m sorry it doesn’t!

Reply

26 Susannah (Lemon and Coconut) October 26, 2015
Recipe Rating:

Thanks so much for this post it’s just what I need to be encouraged to make my own spice mix and also take control of my spice drawer, which is chaotic at the moment! :)

Reply

27 Charlotte October 26, 2015

This looks and sounds absolutely delicious. Great photos too, you definitely know how to make people hungry!

Charlotte xx
http://www.smudgeness.co.uk

Reply

28 Beth October 26, 2015

This is such a cute idea and perfect for a present. I am definitely going to give this a go.

Beth x
http://www.hellobeth.co.uk

Reply

29 Dana C October 26, 2015

I’d love to make these for family and friends! Where did you get the spice jars to fill up?

Reply

30 Angela (Oh She Glows) October 26, 2015

I think they are from Crate and Barrel :)

Reply

31 Jill October 26, 2015

Strange that you weren’t able to find pumpkin pie spice mix! But yes, it’s a very easy thing to mix up. I love to grind up my own cloves. They smell so delicious! Grinding coffee beans in the grinder after cloves is always a good idea :)

Reply

32 Angela @ Eat Spin Run Repeat October 26, 2015

Ok, you’ve just added yet another cookbook to my Christmas wish list this year!! :) I totally hear you on the frustration of not being able to find pumpkin pie spice mix.. and when I do, it costs SO much for the tiniest little jar! I’m all for DIY and saving $$ so I’ll be making Lisa and Nicole’s version in a large batch for sure!

Reply

33 Alice October 26, 2015

Mace is a necessary ingredient to be happiest – it adds something special. It’s actually the whole reason I keep Mace around my kitchen. (It’s part of the same plant as nutmeg – not anything like the concept of “mace the weapon”)

Reply

34 Angela (Oh She Glows) October 26, 2015

Ah yes, I have been meaning to try that! Will pick some up :)

Reply

35 Carol James October 26, 2015

This is great and I will definitely be making some. I already make my own taco seasoning. Just an idea but if you substitute “part” for teaspoons in the recipe you can extend the recipe as much as you want. So if you’re using a 1/4 cup measure you can make a large batch and share it. (Eg. 2x 1/4 cup or 1/2 X 1/4 cup) I then write the amounts (2 parts cinnamon…) on a label and keep it on the jar in my cupboard so it is at my finger tips when I need to replace it. You can then substitute whichever measure gives you the desired amount of seasoning. If you are going to sell it at a market use a cup, if you only want enough for a pie (!?) use a teaspoon.

Reply

36 Paige October 26, 2015

I love making my own pumpkin pie spice! So much cheaper than what I’ve ever been able to find in the store!

Paige
http://thehappyflammily.com

Reply

37 Bella B October 26, 2015

This would be a great gift for all my pumpkin spice loving friends! I will have to try it. ♡♡

xoxoBella | http://xoxobella.com

Reply

38 Charlie October 26, 2015

This recipe is right up my alley! I love making my own spice mixes instead of buying pre-mixed. Thanks for sharing! – Charlie, http://www.lemonbutterlove.com

Reply

39 Bethany @ Athletic Avocado October 26, 2015

I never even thought about making my own pumpkin pie spice mix! I have all spices on hand so I will give it a try!

Reply

40 Svetlana October 26, 2015

Haha it’s good to know that I am not the only one obsessively looking for a pumpkin spice mix in EVERY. SINGLE. MARKET I go to lol. Thank you, thank you, thank you! I can finally do it myself!!! Woohooo

Reply

41 Svetlana October 26, 2015

Please tell me part two is a scone!!!! *Waiting in anticipation*

Reply

42 Liz October 26, 2015

I can’t wait to make this! I see pancakes in my future! ;) And what a brilliant idea to gift them.

Reply

43 Anna Lee October 26, 2015

Thank you for this! I can’t believe I’ve never thought to make my own pumpkin pie spice. I absolutely never have it on hand as it is so expensive in stores, but now I’ll be able to have my own homemade spice! Thanks!

Reply

44 anna October 27, 2015

@ Matea: No, allspice is not a blend of spices. It is actually a spice of its own, originally known as “Jamaica pepper”. The Latin name is Pimenta dioica (living as I do in S. Europe I find the Latin names of herbs and spices useful, to make sure what they sell me is what I want.) You can substitute a combination of equal parts of nutmeg, cinnamon and clove but the flavour will of course be slightly different.

Reply

45 Hester October 27, 2015

Is pumpkin pie spice mix the same as pumpkin spice mix?? (I’m not from the US/Canada so this is new to me!)

Reply

46 Taylor October 27, 2015

Finding it a teensy bit hard to believe you’ve been searching high and low for pumpkin spice mix for ages, to no avail; that a quick recipe search on Google couldn’t solve this problem for you in 5 seconds; that all hope was lost, your sanity was waning, woe was you, etc., until you came across this miraculous recipe! That, by my estimate anyway, will end up costing more than a store-bought bottle of pumpkin spice mix (all those individual ingredients? They’re just as expensive to buy new, and if you’re the sort of person who already has them all on hand, then you probably know how to mix your own pumpkin spice already). Or that a couple of weeks ago you created and posted a recipe for a “Homemade Pumpkin Spice Latte With Salted Pumpkin Spice Syrup” – containing many of the same ingredients and actually suggests pumpkin pie spice mix as a garnish – but couldn’t figure out where or how to get your hands on a spice mix that, yes, has always been vegan and, this time of year, is. Literally. Everywhere.

I really like your blog and your book, and I’m looking forward to OSG#2. But the desperate and dramatic bit? It comes off a bit dumb, and you’re better than that.

Reply

47 Jo November 9, 2015

Wow. You took this post a bit seriously didn’t you!

Reply

48 dave November 12, 2015

So… we shouldn’t take you seriously?

Reply

49 Casey October 27, 2015

Oh, yum! This looks perfect and so easy to make :)

Best,

https://www.theliterarycove.wordpress.com

Reply

50 Anna October 28, 2015

nice!! looks amazing can’t wait to try :D

https://aspoonfulofnature.wordpress.com/

Reply

51 kristi October 28, 2015
Recipe Rating:

The store bought mix has sulphites, so this is a way better option.

Reply

52 Angela (Oh She Glows) October 31, 2015

Wow I wouldn’t have thought that…good to know!

Reply

53 zonderzooi October 30, 2015

This is exactly what I need! I’ve found many recipes online and they all needed pumpkin spice. We don’t have it anywhere in Dutch supermarkets and ordering it from the USA is a bit too expensive. Thank you for this one!

Reply

54 Jane October 30, 2015
Recipe Rating:

I’m not really a fan of pumpkin spice, do you know any yummy desserts we can where we can use it?

Reply

55 KJ | Om Nom Herbivore November 3, 2015

I’m almost out of Pumpkin Pie Spice! I’ll have to give this a try :) By the way, your pictures are amazing!!

Reply

56 Patti November 10, 2015

Trader Joe’s. Two bucks. No sulfites. cinnamon, ginger, lemon peel, nutmeg, cloves, cardamom. For the time challenged. ;)

Reply

57 Avi November 12, 2015
Recipe Rating:

This goes perfect for October/November when we are obsessed with pumpkins.

Reply

58 Barbara K November 18, 2015
Recipe Rating:

Great recipe.. I only had whole allspice, so used it and mixed the ingredients in my coffee grinder. Thanks for the recipe.

Reply

59 Nirupama November 23, 2015

Hey Angela,

On my trip to the USA last year, I fell in love with all things pumpkin there! Lucky, that I decided to be there around fall! Although I brought back how much ever I could of the pumpkin spice flavoured stuff, I have been missing those ever since. Thank you for this amazing recipe and I can’t wait to try it out!
But only one lil problem – I don’t get all spice in India and the substitute mix recipe I found online are already included in your mix. So what to do? It’ll be great if you could help :)

Love,
Niru

Reply

60 Jane November 27, 2015

I’m not really a fan of pumpkin spice. Can you tell me the health benefits we can get from it?

Reply

61 Crystal November 28, 2015
Recipe Rating:

When I am substituting the pumpkin pie spice instead of the ingredients individually how much pumpkin pie spice do I use???

Reply

62 zilla December 8, 2015
Recipe Rating:

Just made these muffins using whole wheat pastry flour (which I always use instead of white). Also used a tsp of ground ginger, a tsp of cinnamon, a pinch nutmeg and pinch allspice. I used less sweetener (molasses and brown sugar).They are really good and I’ll probably have to restrain myself from eating too many right out of the oven.

Reply

63 Surati Ivey December 26, 2015

This is good idea. I’ve been making my own for each recipe fresh.
One time, a long long time ago – I ate a piece of sweet potato pie that had the traditional flavor, but the combination and ratio of spices were the best flavor I had ever had, I mean EVER. Many times the pies too brown with spices, this one was not. And many times I find the flavor overwhelming to the filling. But mostly the clove flavor predominates. Getting that perfect and amazing combination of spices is my goal. Just sayin….. That particular sweet potato pie haunts my taste buds, calling me back to it.

Reply

64 Carla December 30, 2015
Recipe Rating:

I couldnt helped bt try your pumpkin spice mix immediately and best of all I had all the ingredients on hand. Im hooked! I refuse to have my apple bannana green smoothie without it. Thanks a million

Reply

65 Paula January 27, 2016

This looks delicious. If you are ever out and looking to buy some again, bulk barn sells it (IN BULK- so you can buy as much as you want!)

Thanks for the post

Reply

66 Airyfairycelt March 14, 2016
Recipe Rating:

So good to,have the spice explained! It seems to be taken for granted in America but in Ireland….it is a case of looking this up and then we get to enjoy world foods too. I love to eat me us from different countries and often play the music to match too!

Reply

67 Deborah Chester March 17, 2016

The ad I saw you on said there was a slimming drink but when you clicked on it it had all these recipes but nothing about the slimming drink. Was that a trick just for folks to see your website? I won’t sign up for it until I can get the information on the slimming drink.

Reply

68 Colleen Parker April 24, 2016

This Pumpkin Pie Spice mix looks amazing. I have got to try it!! I love your blog, so many excellent, healthy recipes !!

Reply

69 Angela Liddon April 25, 2016

Aw, you’re too sweet Colleen, thank you! It’s wonderful to hear how much you enjoy my blog. If you try the spice mix, I hope you love it!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: