• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Oh She Glows
Menu
  • Recipe Search
  • Cookbook Recipes
  • Recipe Categories
  • App
  • My Cookbooks
  • About
    • Close
Home » Recipes » Restaurant Reviews

New York City: The Last Day

December 4, 2011

IMG_0265

Day 3, the final day in NYC! More walking, more exploring, more great food, and more blisters! Eric joked that I had more moleskin on my feet than an ultra marathoner. A word of advice: Do not break in shoes on a trip to NYC!

IMG_4953

We picked up a few Christmas gifts at FAO Schwarz, a huge toy store filled with neat things.

IMG_0394 IMG_0397

Fish’s Eddy…a really cool kitchenware store!

IMG_0403 IMG_0404

It’s too bad I couldn’t pack much in my suitcase or this store could have been trouble!

IMG_0401

I love all of their bright coloured dishware.

IMG_0402

Then we ended up at the Union Square Market.

IMG_0424

What a GREAT market! This was so much fun.

IMG_0419 IMG_0409

IMG_0410 IMG_0411

IMG_0414 IMG_0417

I picked up something I’ve been looking all over my hometown for…Smoked Paprika!

IMG_0420 IMG_0421 IMG_0422 IMG_0425

We got some HOT mulled apple cider. I burned my tongue over all the excitement.

IMG_0426 IMG_0427

After the market, it was time to eat again! Walk and eat. Eat and walk. This time, we had lunch at Angelica Kitchen.

IMG_0449

Eric ordered the cold apple cider and I ordered a veggie juice.

IMG_0432 IMG_0434

Mid-drink I realized there was a celebrity sitting outside the restaurant! It’s Liev Schreiber from X-men & other films. He was on his cell phone for a good 30 mins or so.

IMG_0433

We actually had no idea what his name was so we sent the pic to a friend who quickly identified him for us. :)

I read that his mom raised him a vegetarian, so maybe he had been dining in the restaurant?

To start, we shared the Agrarian Salgado made up of baked rounds of mashed Yukon Gold potatoes and herbed seitan with a parsley-almond pesto centre; topped with dill-tofu sour cream & garnished with piquant marinated kale.

IMG_0435

Oh my word this was fantastic!!! One of our fav dishes of the entire trip! It tasted just like a croquette, but only better. The dill sauce was outstanding too.

IMG_0437

We also got some sourdough on the side with onion butter.

IMG_0438

For Eric’s main, he ordered one of the specials- “Tales of the Onion” made up with savoury quinoa-vegetable croquettes with b’nut squash, carrots, celery, and chopped parsley; crowned with tarragon cream and served over green split pea sauce. It also came with broccoli and roasted turnips garnished with tatsoi and radicchio.

IMG_0441

He raved about this dish…as did I. The croquettes were really flavourful and crispy and the sauces went lovely with the dish.

I ordered off the special menu too- the “A-meze-ing Stories” which is a Mediterranean meze plate featuring an assortment of vegetables including grilled portobello and button mushrooms red & green peppers, onions and carrots served with a creamy white-bean basil pate, baked garlic chips, and a spelt-berry salad tossed with a hazelnut kalamata olive-caper pesto. With Brussels sprouts and arugula too. That was a mouthful!!

IMG_0444

It was also incredible. I thought the hazelnut olive caper pesto was a really fun idea for a pesto. Normally, I’m not a big olive fan, but I really enjoyed it.

IMG_0446

Wait, I just remembered I had more with my meal! A side of sea vegetables and quinoa. :)

IMG_0443

With “no room left for dessert”, we each enjoyed some tea before heading out to explore the rest of the afternoon.

However, SOMEHOW we ended up stuffing our faces with vegan baked goods not long after!! I really have no idea how this happened…

Hello Babycakes!

IMG_0329

This was our second stop into Babycakes.

It’s a little hole in the wall down some random side street…it took us a while to find it! The interior is really cute, but they have a sign saying no pictures.

IMG_0330

I’ve heard great things about the Babycakes’ apple toastie bread as well as the doughnuts, so I picked up an Apple Cranberry Toastie, pumpkin cupcake, and a chocolate crunch doughnut.

IMG_0331

Apple cran toastie:

IMG_0333

They were all delicious. I think my fav was the toastie bread and Eric’s was the doughnut. Very fresh and sweet, but not overly so. We shared the doughnut and then saved the rest for later…

IMG_0348

I also had something else on my list to try from Atlas Cafe in East Village. This is such a fun cafe with a HUGE menu written all over the walls in chalk.

IMG_0346

Then, somehow this happened…

IMG_0477 IMG_0469IMG_0468 IMG_0476

We shared a pumpkin cupcake from Babycakes and a Peanut Butter BOMB Brownie (added to clarify about the brownie: by Vegan Treats) as found in Atlas Cafe.

OMG….that brownie!!!!! Check it out.

IMG_0472

Here is a better picture of it:

pbbomb

[source]

It’s made up of a thin and dense brownie base topped with a cloud-like peanut butter mousse, a chocolate shell, and a peanut butter drizzle. Heaven.

This brownie is on my must make list. It was one of the best things we tasted on the trip, hands down.Eric doesn’t even like peanut butter and he could not stop gushing over this brownie. If you are near Atlas Cafe anytime soon you gotta order a PB bomb brownie as soon as possible. You won’t regret it!

We ended the trip with a great meal at Pure Food & Wine, followed by a stop at a bar on the way home. It was a great finish to the trip.

For just 3 days, I think we really packed in a lot! Literally. ;)

Has anyone seen my elastic waist pants?

More Restaurant Reviews

  • thingsimlovinglately-5013
    11 Things I’m Loving Lately – The Candy, Portland, & Kitchen Tool Edition!
  • st-jacobs-farmers-market-4428
    St. Jacob’s Farmer’s Market, Fresh Restaurant, and Other Fun
  • IMG_3276
    Naked Sprout Meet Up & Other Weekend Fun
  • jamiepeachey-2
    Green Restaurant

Filed Under: Restaurant Reviews, Travel Tagged With: angelicas cafe nyc review, new york city

Subscribe
Notify of
Check this box so that we can filter out the questions and respond to you quicker.
Recipe Rating
Made this recipe? Leave a review.

95 Comments
carri
14 years ago

feels like we were
on the trip with you!
what a fun trip.
i heart NY.
AND
i LOOOOOOve me some babycakes.
we have one (almost 2) in LA.
next time you MUST
get the choc. chip cookie sandwich.
insanity of amazingness.

ps. totally random,
but is there a way you could
make the external links
open in a new window?
i always click on your links
but it takes me away
from your site, bablhblha…

anyhoo…big LOVE for your BLOG!

Reply
Katie
14 years ago

Yum! I love the chocolate and peanut butter combo. Anything with the two together is a must have in my books!

Reply
Passerby
14 years ago

I just wanna say your trip looks so amazing and I like your blog a lot simply because you never fail to send positive messages to all your readers out there about how maintaining a healthy lifestyle also means indulging once in a while and eating should never be something to fret or worry about as long as in moderation.

I’d love to read more about you blogging how you overcome eating disorder though, if that’s okay. You speak our hearts out so well.

Reply
Angela Liddon (Oh She Glows)
Author
Reply to  Passerby
14 years ago

Thank you for your feedback!

I’ve written about my recovery quite a bit over the years, but this post in particular comes to mind: http://ohsheglows.com/2010/01/17/5-things-that-helped-me-beat-the-obsession/

Reply
Jennifer @ Peanut Butter and Peppers
14 years ago

Ahhh, I’m disappointed you have to leave, I love all the pictures and I so want to get some of those kitchen bowls. Have a great day!

Reply
Melinda
14 years ago

Great day! You hit up 3 of my faves- the market, Angelica Kitchen and Babycakes. My aunt lives in NYC and on visits those are some of the places we must go to. If you are ever back in NYC and need vegan suggestions, let me know. My aunt and sister have scoped them all out.

Reply
Angela @ Eat Spin Run Repeat
14 years ago

Wow, wow, WOW! I don’t think I would have been able to control myself in Fish Eddie! Definitely going to check out their website to see if they ship to Canada. :) I’ve loved every single one of these NYC posts Ange. Beautiful photos!

Reply
The Mrs @ Success Along the Weigh
14 years ago

Wow only 3 days and saw all of that! You must be an itinerary girl like me! I love to maximize everything you see in a new place. I have added the bakery to my folder because I must have that brownie! I would’ve seen Liev and exclaimed “look, it’s Cotton Weary!”

Reply
Anne M
14 years ago

Loved reading all about your NYC adventures, Angela (and left the screen each time with a growling stomach!)
Thanks for the great “reporting”!

Reply
Kristen @ Popcorn on the Stove
14 years ago

I love Atlas Cafe (although I go to Little Atlas which is a tiny branch of theirs). I LOVE getting treats from there – my favorite is their chocolate whoopie pies. They’re out of this world!!

Reply
Hayley @ Oat Couture
14 years ago

Gahhh I NEED to go back to NYC!! Love this post and everything in it!!! :)

Reply
jenna
14 years ago

are you kidding me??? these desserts look to die for!! i’m dying to get to nyc just for these desserts now! lol what an awesome time you all had!!

Reply
Callie @ Callieflower Kitchen
14 years ago

Looks like you guys are having a fun trip! Babycakes was one of my favourite cupcake places in NYC, even including the non-vegan ones.

Also, they sell smoked paprika at Loblaws in the spice aisle, just FYI :)

Reply
VeggieGirl
14 years ago

love the spice photo, reminds me of India

Reply
Cortnie
14 years ago

One of my favorite things about traveling is EATING! You guys know how to live it up. ;)

xo
cortnie

Reply
Kaitlyn@TheTieDyeFiles
14 years ago

What a fantastic trip, and that brownie looks absolutely phenomenal. The boyfriend has family in NYC and he just suggested we plan a trip! I bet he’d be down with trying that brownie :)

Reply
Jolene (www.everydayfoodie.ca)
14 years ago

Fish’s Eddy is SUCH a cool store!!! LOVE that place, but spent waaaaaay too much money there! That is very cool that you saw a celebrity!!

Reply
Lauren @ Sweet and Twisted
14 years ago

I live by Vegan Treats! I’m not vegan but we still stop there sometimes! So decadent and yummy looking!

Reply
Andrea
14 years ago

I was there a couple of weeks before you and looove the Union Square market. I can’t resist a farmers’ market anywhere. They feel like home.

I was supposed to go to Angelica Kitchen but plans changed. It’s on my list for next time. My friend said that he’d spotted Katie Holmes there the day before, so it seems to be popular among people who work in show business – though I’m not sure that two celebrities is enough to prove that theory.

I had the Babycakes apple cranberry toastie too, though now I realized that I misidentified it in my own blog entry.

Reply
The Healthy Apple
14 years ago

Wish I knew you were here in NYC; would have loved to see you! So glad you had a fun time. Happy Holidays!

Reply
Alex
14 years ago

I live on the same block as Angelica’s. It’s my favorite!!! I’m glad you got to experience it :)

Reply
« Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

About Angela

I’m Angela, the founder of Oh She Glows. Since 2008, I’ve been on a journey to glow from the inside out by creating crowd-pleasing plant-based recipes. I’m a New York Times Bestselling cookbook author and award-winning app creator. Click below for my full story!
Read More

Pre-Order Oh She Glows Salads

Trending Now

  • Ultra Creamy Hemp Salad Dressing + Salad Recipe
  • Vegan "Turtle" Oatmeal Cookies
  • Raspberry Almond Thumbprint Cookies (Gluten-Free and Vegan)

Footer

Oh She Glows

  • My Story
  • The App
  • My Cookbooks
  • OSG in the Media
  • Archives

Popular

  • Recipe Search
  • Recipe Index
  • Cookbook Index
  • My Favourite Skin Care Products
  • My Most-Used Kitchen Tools

Follow on Social Media

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2026 Oh She Glows. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
Want to see more Oh She Glows recipes in your Google results? Click here to add us as a preferred source.

An Elite CafeMedia Food Publisher

Oh She Glows Salads, is here!

Inside my latest cookbook, you’ll find crowd-pleasing plant-based salads, satisfying toppers, bold flavour boosters, and vibrant dressings that will completely change how
you see salads.

Plus…

  • Make-ahead tips and shortcuts
  • Storage and reheating guidance
  • Seasonal salad chapters
  • A delectable plant-based dessert chapter
  • Over 100 full-colour photographs
  • How to craft irresistible salad dressings
Purchase Oh She Glows Salads from Amazon
Purchase Oh She Glows Salads from Barnes & Noble