Peanut Butter & Jam Graham Cracker Sandwiches

121 comments

IMG_8478

Happy Friday to you!

I just wanted to let you guys know that my spam checker is marking some comments randomly as ‘spam’ and I am not sure what is going on. I have approved several spam comments from the past few days and I will keep a close eye on it. I’m sorry if that was happening to you and you didn’t know why! I will monitor the situation and report to the computer authorities if necessary (aka Eric).

Today, we talk homemade graham crackers. For the second time.

I’ve been quite smitten with homemade graham crackers ever since I fell in love with them back in December after adapting a recipe from Ashley.

Last week, I was feeling frisky and I made a PB + J graham cracker sandwich using two homemade graham crackers, raspberry jam, and peanut butter.

I think this photo speaks for itself…

IMG_8480

I just loved how the peanut butter, jam, and graham flavours all went together and I was instantly hooked!

And then I started to imagine how delicious a peanut butter graham cracker would be….

IMG_8409

Three trials later, I am happy to share my favourite version with you.

IMG_8436

IMG_8391

These graham crackers are quite fun to make. First you mix the modified flax egg and then set aside.

Now, grab those dry ingredients…

IMG_8395

IMG_8396

Whisk together.

IMG_8398

Assemble the wet ingredients and the gelled up flax egg.

IMG_8404

Add to a bowl.

IMG_8412

Whisk.

IMG_8418

Add wet to dry..

IMG_8423

It will be very thick and you will have to get in there with your hands to mix in the ingredients fully.

IMG_8424

Squeeze the dough in your hands until most of the flour is mixed in.

IMG_8426

Form a ball.

IMG_8427

Break the ball in half and then roll out on a floured surface. I used my new Silpat mat that I got at Christmas and it was a great non-stick surface for rolling dough!

IMG_8432

The only thing I do not like about the dough is that it cracks a bit (this was true for all trials that I did), so try not to roll it too thin or it will fall apart.

Use cookie cutters if preferred.

IMG_8438

IMG_8439

You can even make cute little hearts for Valentine’s Day!

IMG_8441

Or maybe you’d rather stab a square with a fork…

IMG_8443

Place in the oven for 15-18 minutes at 350F. Rotate half way through. The amount of time you have to bake will depend on how thick they are. The crackers should be slightly firm when coming out of the oven.

IMG_8444

Allow to cool for about 30 minutes. The graham crackers will really crisp up during this time.

The result is a delicious homemade graham cracker with a hint of peanut butter flavour!

IMG_8448

Peanut Butter S’more anyone?

IMG_8458-2

Or maybe PB + J?

IMG_8477

IMG_8478

They are pretty insane.

IMG_8464-2

I think I slightly prefer this version over the last ones I made. This version has less of a molasses flavour to allow the peanut butter flavour to come through and it just seems to work really well.

IMG_8469-2

Have a great start to your weekend!

Let's get social! Follow Angela on Instagram (@ohsheglows + @theglowspot), Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Snapchat, and Google+

Previous Posts

{ 121 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Alicia January 7, 2011

You never cease to amaze me!!! These look so yummmmy!! Have a great day :)

Reply

2 sarah January 7, 2011

my afternoon tea today!!

Reply

3 Sruthi @ Exercise, Food & Beyond January 7, 2011

I never tried making graham crackers at home. My sister is a big fan of graham crackers, will send her this recipe, she will love it.

Reply

4 Maria @ runningcupcake January 7, 2011

They look so good! I like the idea of the hint of ginger in them too.
:)

Reply

5 Picky Nicky January 7, 2011

If only you knew how much I want to reach into my screen right now and snatch one :)

Reply

6 Maddie (Healthy Maddie) January 7, 2011

I’ve never made graham crackers before but now I really want to! These look awesome.

Reply

7 Tess January 7, 2011

What do you use for marshmallows in the s’mores? I’ve had a hard time finding vegan (or even vegetarian!) ones.

Reply

8 Angela (Oh She Glows) January 7, 2011

I use Dandie’s Brand..they taste just like reg marshmallows and cook similar too.
http://www.chicagosoydairy.com/dandies_vegan_marshmallows/

Reply

9 bitt of raw January 7, 2011

sweet and sara makes some too. in smaller packages.

Reply

10 Bethany @ More Fruit Please January 7, 2011

I was the queen of peanut butter and graham crackers as a kid… why did I never think to add jam into the mix???

Reply

11 rebecca lustig January 7, 2011

oh my gosh, you totally re invented a childhood favorite of mine! but more homemade, of course

Reply

12 Tiffany @ Conor & Bella January 7, 2011

That s’mores one really got me. Ohh man.

Reply

13 Ashley @ Taste for Healthy January 7, 2011

I have been seriously craving peanut butter lately… so I was extremely excited when I saw the title of this post!! They look like heaven! :) Thank you for sharing your baking brilliance once again!!!

I hope you have a great weekend!! :)

Reply

14 Madeleine@ Stepping to the Brightside January 7, 2011

I love the heart-shaped cookie cutters :) I tried the chocolate graham cracker recipe over Christmas- I found that it really matters how long they stay in the oven. I took the first batch out too early and the the texture was off- more chewy than crispy but when I kept them in a litttttle longer than I thought necessary, they were perfection. Trial and error can be fun! (Sometimes…)

Reply

15 thefruitpursuit (Sabine) January 7, 2011

These look so cute and delicious! Will try soon!

x sabine

Reply

16 Stefanie January 7, 2011

The perfect graham cracker. I like it and will have to give it a try. Thank you. :)

Reply

17 thefruitpursuit (Sabine) January 7, 2011

Ps I checked out my health food store today to get brown rice syrup and only saw regular rice syrup. do you think it’s a big difference in taste/nutr value/consistency?

Reply

18 Angela (Oh She Glows) January 7, 2011

im not sure, I have not seen/used reg rice syrup before!

Reply

19 Amanda (Eating Up) January 7, 2011

Those look perfect! Way better than box ones for sure. And I’ve never seen a pb graham cracker!

Reply

20 Lauren January 7, 2011

PB graham cracker s’mores would be fabulous!

Reply

21 Tina @ Faith Fitness Fun January 7, 2011

I’ve noticed the same thing with my spam too. So odd!

Reply

22 Allison @ Food For Healing January 7, 2011

the PB & J combo would be an absolute dream! nice work

Reply

23 Sonia January 7, 2011

PB and jam always makes a good mix yum yum yum. Adding graham crackers with them should be delightful. can’t wait to try these.

Reply

24 Emma (Sweet Tooth Runner) January 7, 2011

Oh heavenly yum! I am drooling over here! :D
And I love your cute cookie cutter!

Reply

25 Laura @ Starting Out Fit January 7, 2011

Finally something I actually have all the ingredients for in the house! ;)
I think my fiance and I will be having peanut butter graham crackers for dessert tonight :)

Reply

26 Paije January 7, 2011

I made little PB&J sandwiches the last time I made ashley’s graham crackers! I could probably eat them for the rest of my life and die happy! Peanut butter s’mores though?! Heaaaven.

Reply

27 Kate (What Kate is Cooking) January 7, 2011

Delicious! I used to eat something similar when I was a kid :)

Reply

28 Mauimandy@The Grains of Paradise January 7, 2011

Cute idea! Me like!! Reminds me of grade school…..

Reply

29 Bridget January 7, 2011

That mearuing cup overflowing with peanut butter made my mouth water!! Looooove it!

Reply

30 Pam landy January 7, 2011

I wish I could be a taste tester for your recipes!

Reply

31 Averie (LoveVeggiesAndYoga) January 7, 2011

“Peanut Butter S’more anyone?”—OH YES PLEASE!

These look awesome, Angela! I love graham crackers. Love.Them. But I dont buy them b/c they arent vegan or GF usually so I need to try making my own version. I remember your last post, I said I was going to make some..havent done that yet…but gosh, you have me wanting to!

And wow, the cookie cutter w/ Heart shapes. Valentines Day…Can’t believe that is coming up…already! Time flies!

Enjoy your weekend :)

Reply

32 Meagan January 7, 2011

Looks and sounds delicious! Graham crackers are a fav! I will definitely have to try :)

Reply

33 Megan (Braise The Roof) January 7, 2011

Sometimes your recipes are so obvious that they’re genius! Peanut butter IN the graham cracker? That would have saved me a lot of peanut butter application onto graham crackers when I had it for a snack every day in college!

Reply

34 Nichole January 7, 2011

I bet the kiddies would love these!!!

Reply

35 Cathy Breit January 7, 2011

I’ve been eyeing ashley’s graham crackers forever! Need to get on this one, stat!
love,
cathy b. @ brightbakes
P.S.that first pic ignited a powerful PB craving in me…scary stuff!

Reply

36 Jil @ Big City, Lil Kitchen January 7, 2011

These looks so amazing – I wish I had your skills! :)

Reply

37 Angela @ Eat Spin Run Repeat January 7, 2011

These sound delicious! I love graham crackers and your heart shaped ones are so cute. Definitely on my must-make list! :)

Reply

38 salah@myhealthiestlifestyle January 7, 2011

those sandwiches look great!!

Reply

39 emma January 7, 2011

These look seriously fabulous! We don’t have Graham crackers or s’mores over here in the UK :-( I didn’t even know what they were until I started blogging! Might have to make my very first s’more soon :-) x x

Reply

40 Alex @ La Beauté January 7, 2011

That looks delicious! Can’t wait to make homemade s’mores!

Reply

41 Heather (Heather's Dish) January 7, 2011

FABULOUS recipe! i’ve had pb&j graham crackers since i was a kiddo, and this is takin’ me right back :)

Reply

42 Traci(faithfulfoodiefashionista) January 7, 2011

Nothing better than the ol stand by with peanut butter and jelly :) I am going to have to give these graham crackers a try. I don’t think I have ever told you this but I love that hot pink spatula spoon in a lot of your pics :) Happy Friday!

Reply

43 Marina January 7, 2011

Mhm, these look so delicious!
I probably could eat ton of them, with a glass of cold milk

Reply

44 Amanda (Sweet and Savory Vegan) January 7, 2011

Wow, that peanut butter s’more looks insane. I’m not sure why I’ve never thought to make my own graham crackers before, especially when vegan ones can be tricky to find. Thanks for the inspiration.

Reply

45 suz January 7, 2011

these look really good. i have been wanting to try to make some vegan graham crackers. also on a side note- may i ask what service you use for your website? thanks. :)

Reply

46 Mary Allison January 7, 2011

That appears to be heaven on a plate! OMG. I may have to make this TONIGHT!

Reply

47 Stacey (The Habit of Healthy) January 7, 2011

Erm…..these look delicious! But then you knew that anyway! ;)

Reply

48 Alycia [Fit n Fresh] January 7, 2011

Amazing spin on graham crackers!! I need to take a whole weekend and get crazy with the baking I think lol

Reply

49 Dani @ Body By Nature January 7, 2011

Drool! These look delicious!

Reply

50 Hillary [Nutrition Nut on the Run] January 7, 2011

tasty! now you just need ash’s roasted maple cinnamon almond butter inside ;)

Reply

51 Jemma @ Celery and Cupcakes January 7, 2011

These look delicious!!!

Reply

52 wendy (healthy girl's kitchen) January 7, 2011

This is all so very Martha Stewart of you! (I LOVE her style, by the way). But I’ve got a few probing questions for you. (1) How do you have the time to do all of this? Do you “have a day job”? and even more importantly (2) how do you keep such goodies around your home without overpartaking in them, if you know what I mean . . .

Reply

53 Angela (Oh She Glows) January 7, 2011

My jobs are running/owning a bakery (Glo Bakery) and writing this blog.

As for leftovers, Eric brings them to work to share with coworkers.

Reply

54 wendy (healthy girl's kitchen) January 7, 2011

Oh! I get it now! Sorry for being slow on the uptake! I’ll go take a look at your vegan goodies . . .

Reply

55 Kris | iheartwellness.com January 7, 2011

Hubba Hubba, I am in love over here!!! I think I can manage to eat one or two of these bad boys ;)

I must try these gluten free!!

xxoo

Reply

56 Katie January 7, 2011

Your recipes are nothing short of genius. PB IN the graham cracker AND on it?? THat’s a PBJ I can get into!

Reply

57 Kristin (Cook, Bake, Nibble) January 7, 2011

Oh wow. Now I’m drooling all over my new computer, thanks. :P
I’ve always been nervous to make my own graham crackers, but I really should- to make these!!

xo

Reply

58 Angela (Oh She Glows) January 7, 2011

im so glad ur comments are coming through!

Reply

59 Michelle @ Give Me the Almond Butter January 7, 2011

PB&J graham crackers would be such a fantastic snack! Thanks for the great idea!

Reply

60 Andrea January 7, 2011

Pretty! I love putting pb & j on my regular graham crackers, so I can only imagine that it’s even better with pb in the crackers themselves :) Pumpkin butter + pb is another graham cracker topping combo I love, super delish.

Reply

61 Healthy Chocoholic January 7, 2011

PB makes (almost) everything better!
Great recipe!!!!

Reply

62 lili January 7, 2011

i cannot stop singing the praises of peanut butter.
Seriously.
After going on for like 10 min how much i loved the freshly ground almond butter at the coop i realized the room was now empty :) hehe. oops.

Reply

63 Moni'sMeals January 7, 2011

yes! I love your recipe here, It is still on my “I want to make…List!”

I adore the heart cutter too. :)

Reply

64 Laura @ Sprint 2 the Table January 7, 2011

one day i am going to have to muster the kahunas to try making graham crackers. homemade s’mores look too good to pass up!

Reply

65 bitt of raw January 7, 2011

I am having a major PB craving now! interesting twist on the graham cracker.

Reply

66 Gabriela @ Une Vie Saine January 7, 2011

Your creations never cease to amaze me. Seriously, these are so original!! My dad would really love them.

Reply

67 Christine (The Raw Project) January 7, 2011

My spam filter has been doing the same thing lately, I have to filter out good comments daily. Sometimes it works great, other times not so well. These sandwiches look amazingly delicious! Your creations are so amazing, thanks!

Reply

68 Candice @ ChiaSeedMe January 7, 2011

These look delicious Angela! Especially the peanut butter and jelly one. mmmmm

Also, I’m having the same problem with my spam filter. It really likes a couple of my readers and randomly catches their comments – drives me crazy!

Reply

69 Mary @ Bites and Bliss January 7, 2011

I love, love, love grahams and peanut butter!!!! These look great, thank you!

Reply

70 carlee January 7, 2011

Such a good idea! your brilliant!

Reply

71 Hannah January 7, 2011

I believe I just fell in love with you.

‘Nuff said.

Reply

72 Vivaciousvegan January 7, 2011

Wow, aren’t you creative. I just might have to make these for my randaughter when she gets older! Awesome~

Reply

73 Kat January 7, 2011

I love putting peanut butter on graham crackers. Why didn’t someone think of just combining the two sooner. I will make this as soon as all the treats from Christmas are all gone

Reply

74 Amber K January 7, 2011

Homemade things taste so much better, don’t they? My best friend made some homemade gluten-free graham crackers that were delicious! They didn’t taste like a graham cracker, but could totally replace them for an awesome s’more!

Reply

75 Melissa @ Be Not Simply Good January 7, 2011

Mmm. I see a batch of graham crackers in our near future. We haven’t made any in a long time. Yours look so good and so pretty. :)

Reply

76 Camille January 7, 2011

When I saw this post, I had a little conversation with myself. It went like like,
“Peanut butter graham crackers! Don’t mind if I do! Wait, I do mind, because we don’t have the ingredients.”
It was a sad moment.

Reply

77 Angela (Oh She Glows) January 7, 2011

hah!!! oh you are funny

Reply

78 Maryea {Happy Healthy Mama} January 7, 2011

Graham crackers have been on my list to make since I saw them on Ashley’s blog. My 2 year old would love these as she is a huge PB fan. I gotta get on this!

Reply

79 chelsey @ clean eating chelsey January 7, 2011

I loooooove graham crackers.. and peanut butter! This is a match made in heaven.

Reply

80 Lauren at KeepItSweet January 7, 2011

i NEED to have peanut butter graham crackers in my life!!!

Reply

81 Alaina January 7, 2011

I can taste it already! I love the s’mores one. :-)

Reply

82 Beatrix January 7, 2011

Hmmm….is all I can say :)

Reply

83 stacey-healthylife January 7, 2011

That looks so good, yum. I love the idea of homemade graham crackers.

Reply

84 Sierra January 7, 2011

Hey, Angela,
Do you mind if people repost recipes? I would give you credit, of course. Just wondering. Thanks. :)

Reply

85 Angela (Oh She Glows) January 8, 2011

be my guest :)

Reply

86 Sierra January 8, 2011

You’re a doll! I love you! Eh hem…I mean, your blog! ;) Thank you! :)

Reply

87 Ashley January 7, 2011

Two words: Mouth Watering. Those look so good especially in sandwich form :d

Reply

88 Justeen @ Blissful Baking January 8, 2011

Mmmm peanut butter graham crackers… these sounds absolutely wonderful! So many awesome flavors in one healthy cracker! Yum!

Reply

89 Roz January 8, 2011

Home made graham crackers???? Be still my heart!!! These look amazing.

Reply

90 Bella January 8, 2011

Is there a reason you didn’t use graham flour for these graham crackers?

Reply

91 Jessie January 8, 2011

I’ve been looking for a good healthy snack for the kids. Thinking we will whip up a batch today. Smores sound so good . . . wish we had the 6 burner gas stove that someday will be in my kitchen to roast the marshmallows over!

Reply

92 Paige @Running Around Normal January 8, 2011

Oh yum!! I think I’ll try my hand at these! I have a feeling today is going to be a baking day :) Your granola post the other day inspired me to make some granola, too :D

Reply

93 Melomeals: Vegan for $3.33 a Day January 8, 2011

That sounds sooooo good.

Reply

94 Jo January 8, 2011

Hi Angela,

Do you have the calories per serving attached to your recipes? I thought I saw it once, but I haven’t seen this in a long time. Thank you.

Jo

Reply

95 Diana @ frontyardfoodie January 8, 2011

Holy crap I must make these! I have a terrible love for graham crackers and I think homemade must be a hundred times better.

Reply

96 Adam January 8, 2011

Do you think putting the dough in the fridge for a few hours would make it have better flavor, like the cookies??

Reply

97 Natalia - a side of simple January 8, 2011

I’m in love. Think of all the variations and fillings!

Reply

98 Ashley @ the fit academic January 8, 2011

So cute! I love the little heart-shaped crackers!

Reply

99 liza January 8, 2011

yum! looks good :)

Reply

100 Faith @ lovelyascharged January 8, 2011

Mmm, grown-up version of kiddie favorites :)

Reply

101 Colleen January 8, 2011

They look SO good!!! Probably oodles better than packaged, and a whole lot healthier :)

Reply

102 Rach January 8, 2011

Oh my gracious, those are adorable! And they make me crave peanut butter… haha!

Reply

103 Rach January 8, 2011

Oh my gracious, those are adorable! And they make me crave peanut butter… haha!

Reply

104 Casey January 8, 2011

I just made these, and they are delicious (even when they are a little burnt…oops)!!!!

Reply

105 Kathi January 8, 2011

Just wanted to let you know that the trying making the crackers today. They were a big success even hubby like them and he is resisting the whole vegan tooth and nail.

Have any idea what I can use in replacement for half and half? I used soy creamer but thought maybe you might have some other suggestions. I made a cauliflower soup that called for half and half.

Thanks for your help.

Reply

106 Nicole January 8, 2011

Those look AMAZING. Could I use actual graham flour in them, do you think? I have some at home I really need to use up (my mom’s annoyed at the ridiculous number of types of flour that are taking up space in our pantry lol)

Reply

107 jodie January 9, 2011

Oh my goodness. I just made these. Yup addicting. I only had 1 cup of whole wheat flour left so I used 1/2 cup of rye flour and it was still great ( i do love rye flour though).
Thanks for the inspiration. Oh my daughter thinks they are great too. But I think she is just more excited that they were vegan so she could eat the batter!

Reply

108 Kristy January 10, 2011

I’ve realized that usually seek out a “best” version of a recipe I’m trying to make – I make it then a few weeks later I check to see if you or mama pea have a vegan version. :-) Its fun to see the difference in textures and final products! I.E. Now I MUST make vegan graham since I made regular a few weeks back!

Reply

109 Sarah January 14, 2011

Oh my goodness….these are amazing!!! Just made a batch and the house smells heavenly :) I rolled it out between two layers of cling wrap to prevent sticking and it worked a treat. So happy with the outcome!

Reply

110 Sarah Dean January 26, 2011

Hey Angela!
I was hoping you may have a suggestion: I made these this evening with an egg instead of the flax mixture because my grinder(to grind the flax) was broken. They turned out great, but I ended up having ot form them into little balls and flatten them on the cookie sheet because they were incredibly sticky-is this because of the egg maybe? Any suggestions to help this-or should I just add more flour?
Sarah

Reply

111 Tina June 2, 2012

I just made these today after wanting to try them forever. They are absolutely amazing! I only had whole wheat flour on hand and just substituted more maple syrup for the molasses and they are just perfect. Thank you for sharing your ingenuity!

Reply

112 Angela (Oh She Glows) June 2, 2012

Glad you enjoyed them Tina!

Reply

113 Marci June 27, 2012

This look super yummy! My little boy (5 yrs old) loves graham crackers but we need to be gluten free. How would you modify your recipe for the needs of the gluten free people?

Thanks!

Reply

114 Angela (Oh She Glows) June 28, 2012

Hey Marci, I have worked on a GF version a few times before and I didn’t quite nail it yet. I hope to at some point in the future! Im guessing a combo of flours will work best.

Reply

115 Jenny Jensen June 28, 2012

I can’t wait to try this recipe but I can’t take wheat. What should I use as an alternative flour? Love your ideas, so different! X X

Reply

116 Samantha August 16, 2012

Hi! Any thoughts on a flour I could sub in to makes these gluten free? Thanks and, Angela, love your blog. It, plus Momastery.com, is my one break from my daily dose of cynicism. :)

Reply

117 Angela (Oh She Glows) August 16, 2012

Hey Samantha, I’ve tried some GF versions and nothing Im sold on yet. Ill keep working on it!

Reply

118 Samantha August 19, 2012

I’m going to try them with Thomas Keller’s new gluten free flour. I’ll report back!

Reply

119 jacque September 1, 2013

What would be a good swap for the whole wheat pastry flour to make these gf?

Reply

120 PinaColada February 16, 2014

Where did you get those heart shaped cookie cutters, if you don’t mind sharing? They are so adorable! :)

Reply

121 Chandrika March 6, 2014

I love your blog and find myself coming back to it whenever I need Inspiration. Thank you for sharing such wonderful recipes.. Will certainly try this one…

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: