Salt-Kissed Chunky Peanut Butter Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies

102 comments

Good evening!

Our friend Dan’s birthday get together is tomorrow night and I got this great idea to make Dan healthier vegan chocolate chip cookies. You see, Dan is a great guy and he deserves only the best on his birthday. He also loves my vegan baked goods.

Little did I know that my quest to bake a delicious vegan chocolate chip cookie would take 5 trials! Oye. However, I do not go down without a fight. If it takes 5 trials of taste testing cookies, I will roll up my sleeves and dig in. Someone’s gotta do it.

I started with a classic chocolate chip cookie recipe that one of my family members gave me years ago. I decided it was time to veganize this baby! Out went 1 egg, 1/2 cup butter, and a cup of sugar.

See ya, won’t miss ya, I said.

For some reason, I decided I would also turn this recipe into a s’more cookie. I was feeling a bit crazy and delirious, clearly…

Trial 1:

The S’more sandwich.

20100902-IMG_2025

Hrmm.

It tasted good, but it was nothing to write home about.

Back to the drawing board!

Trial 2:

The S’more Cookie

20100902-IMG_2037

Oozing with vegan marshmallows, it was good, but not great. Nor amazing.

Next!

Trial 3:

Vegan Chunky Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

20100902-IMG_2074

Whoops. It got a little crowded in there! ;)

20100902-IMG_2076

I was sick of the s’more cookies and decided to go back to the classic chocolate chip cookie with a nut butter twist. This version tasted phenomenal, but the cookie was a bit thin for my liking.

I was now on a quest to plump it up!

Trial 4:

The thicker chocolate chip cookie

20100902-IMG_2079

Too thick and cake like. :(

I am now weak. It feels like I have been in the kitchen for days on end. My throat is dry.

This is what happened when I added a chia egg (1 T ground chia + 3 T water) and a bit more flour. Interesting, but much too muffin like in texture and not crispy at all.

I need the crisp factor!

Scratch.

Trial 5:

The Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie…with a twist!

I said a little prayer for this batch. My golden hairs were turning grey. Something had to give….

20100902-IMG_2094

[This recipe is BACK after popular request!! Sorry for the inconvenience guys!]

Salt-Kissed Chunky Peanut Butter Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies

Ingredients:

  • 1 + 1/4 cup whole grain spelt flour* (see note below)
  • 1/4 cup organic sugar
  • 1/4 tsp fleur de sel (or reg. salt)
  • 1/4 tsp baking soda
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • 1.5 tbsp cacao nibs (optional, but they add crunch!)
  • 3-4 tsp non-dairy dark chocolate chips
  • 1.5 tbsp chunky peanut butter
  • 2 tsp pure vanilla extract
  • 1/4 cup pure maple syrup
  • 3.5 tbsp canola oil
  • Fleur de sel, for garnish
  • Turbinado sugar, for garnish (optional)

 

Directions:

  1. Preheat oven to 350F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or spray  with oil. In a large bowl, mix all dry ingredients (spelt flour, baking  soda, baking powder, fleur de sel, sugar).
  2. Whisk together. In a medium  sized bowl mix all wet ingredients (peanut butter, maple syrup, oil.  vanilla). Mix well making sure the PB is thoroughly mixed in.
  3. Now add  wet to dry and stir. Mix with hands if necessary until fully  incorporated. Stir in cacao nibs and chocolate chips. Wet hands and  shape small cookies about 1.5 inches in diameter and place on baking  sheet.
  4. Bake for just 10 minutes. Remove from oven and place on cooling  rack after a couple minutes. Cool for 10 minutes. Makes 14 medium sized  cookies.

See this post for my favourite chocolate chip cookie recipe!

20100902-IMG_2084

Happy Birthday Dan. If we eat all of them before tomorrow night, this post is proof that the thought was there anyways. ;)

Let's get social! Follow Angela on Instagram (@ohsheglows + @theglowspot), Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and Google+

Previous Posts

{ 102 comments… read them below or add one }

1 holly @ couchpotatoathlete September 2, 2010

You can send those “bad” cookies to me! :)

Happy Birthday Dan. If I baked those cookies for you they would be long gone by tomorrow!

Reply

2 Mary @ Bites and Bliss September 2, 2010

Angela, you’re genius. Pure genius. I love all your recipes and this one’s no different. PB..chocolate..cookies?! Heck yes please!! :D

And happy birthday, Dan!

Reply

3 Meredith September 2, 2010

Mmm those look delish! The “flops” don’t look half bad either:)

Reply

4 Hillary [Nutrition Nut on the Run] September 2, 2010

Oh, how I miss the rain. It’s high 90’s today! Enjoy : )

Reply

5 OSGMOM September 2, 2010

Holy Yum! I wish I was there to have one or two or three :)

Reply

6 MoniMeals September 2, 2010

THey Look Great! You had me on the the first one…a smore sandwich…sold! but then the chunky peanut butter chocolate chip cookie… I am sold as well! You needed a litttle taste tester! :) I wish I could reach in and have one. :) Looks perfect to have with the little rain (drizzle) and some warm almond milk or tea, I agree. Great touch with the turbinado sugar

Reply

7 Jessica @ The Process of Healing September 2, 2010

Peanut butter and chocolate… you can’t go wrong there!

Reply

8 Tasha - the clean eating mama September 2, 2010

Fantastic as always! I am always on the hunt for vegan cookies!

Reply

9 Jessica @ Dairy Free Betty September 2, 2010

I think this must be the reason your recipes are always SO good!! I would have given up way before you did!! And now you have all those dangerous cookies lurking in your kitchen.

Good perseverance Ang!! teehee!!

They look amazing!

Reply

10 Emily September 2, 2010

Those look amazing!! I have been looking for a vegan recipe for chocolate chip cookies lately and I think I may have found the one :) Thanks so much for all your hard work and trials !!

Reply

11 Maissa September 2, 2010

This guy is getting bookmarked. Now I know what I’m making the next time I want to bake. I love that it doesn’t ask for any complicated ingredients. Built to be vegan from the ground up with no replacements.
Thanks for sharing these!

Reply

12 Cara September 2, 2010

I am sure all the trails were worth it, those look fabulous.
If only I could bite into one right now!

Reply

13 Rachael September 2, 2010

Fleur de sel is one of the most amazing baking additions I’ve come across – I love the bit of salt with the sweet, and it makes for excellent lemon-tinged sugar cookies!

Reply

14 Jessica @ How Sweet It Is September 2, 2010

Wow… these are dreamy. Love salt + sweet.

Reply

15 Jen September 2, 2010

Those all look delish! And I swear, Hamilton is the only place in Southern Ont. that didn’t get rain today…I’d like a break from this humidity; please send rain stat!

Reply

16 Kristina @ spabettie September 2, 2010

I love topping my brownies and cookies with a little sea salt… YUM

You have my address, right?? I’ll take those s’more cookies off your hands – I’m generous like that :)

Reply

17 Michelle @ Give Me the Almond Butter September 2, 2010

Omigosh those look to die for! I just tried out your mushroom pizza today by the way. It was phenomenal. Here’s the link: http://givemethealmondbutter.wordpress.com/2010/09/02/messes/

Reply

18 Jenn @ LiveWellFitNow September 2, 2010

You my dear a fabulous and true baker!!! Five trials..impressive! ;) and they look delish!

Those will be on my upcoming treat for a rant day

Reply

19 Sonia @ Master of Her Romaine September 2, 2010

Angela- you are UNSTOPPABLE!
I am making these tomorrow. I would make them tonight but I don’t have chocolate chips and I have had too much wine. The cookies must wait.
PS- Thank you so much for your mushroom post!! Mushrooms have been the one food I do not like for such a long time. I have recently (as in last month) started warming up to them, and I love what you did!

Reply

20 Angela (Oh She Glows) September 2, 2010

I used to HATE Portabellas! Now I love all mushrooms.

Reply

21 Rachel (Two Healthy Plates) September 2, 2010

I love cookies with a little bit of saltyness! These look great – I don’t know how you made it through 5 trials, I would have called it a day after just two!

Reply

22 Julie @SavvyEats September 2, 2010

This recipe looks perfect. I need to make these soon!

Reply

23 Stefanie September 2, 2010

Dan is one lucky guy to have a friend like you. Those cookies look yummy. :) I would have never thought to add cocao nibs to add crunch.

Reply

24 The Wife of a Dairyman September 2, 2010

Looks good! ….I would probably substitute butter in mine ;)

Reply

25 Mimi September 2, 2010

A little bit of salt on something sweet makes all the difference. Everyone always asks me what my “trick” is!

Reply

26 Tina September 2, 2010

I don’t think you can get better than fresh baked goods for a gift. Especially for a guy! Great idea.

And I hope you got to enjoy one yourself with a glass of almond milk and relaxing, just listening to the rain. :)

Reply

27 Maria @ Oh Healthy Day September 2, 2010

Dan is one lucky guy. And so is whoever gets to eat all the “duds”.

Reply

28 Angela (Oh She Glows) September 2, 2010

i’ll pawn the duds off on friends…hahah

Reply

29 Heather @ Side of Sneakers September 2, 2010

1. I love how dedicated you are to making the best cookie, no matter how many trials.
2. The final product sounds & looks delicious!

Reply

30 Devyn September 2, 2010

OMG. This post made me crave a cookie so bad and I never really crazy cookies or desserts. I HAD to get a spoon of salty peanut butter haha, but the craving was not resolved! I may have to bake…

Reply

31 Rhea (Greek Feaster) September 2, 2010

What a sweet friend you are! The cookies look great- I love salty and sweet. Example: I would love to make a cocoa-based cookie with pretzel bits :D

Reply

32 Maddie September 2, 2010

Wow those look delicious! Thanks for the recipe. I have to bake a dessert for a cross country running party tomorrow and was looking for something new. Who doesn’t love peanut butter and chocolate chips?

Reply

33 MJ September 2, 2010

They look delish! Though I wouldn’t mind the recipe for the s’more cookies. please.

Reply

34 Bridget September 2, 2010

Mmmm cookies! This recipe looks fabulous! I’m guessing that I could use coconut oil in place of canola oil. Think that would work?

Reply

35 Angela (Oh She Glows) September 2, 2010

I thought about that too…Im not sure how it would change the cookie but might be worth a shot!

Reply

36 Wei-Wei September 2, 2010

What happened to Trials 1-4?! Are you going to eat all of them? Heh. Awesome. I think I’ll try this recipe, but I don’t have any chocolate chips… maybe I’ll just add some walnuts for crunch! Thanks for sharing! (I love your resolve. I think I get mine from you. :D)

Reply

37 Angela (Oh She Glows) September 2, 2010

Will be bringing them to the party

Reply

38 betsy September 2, 2010

Hi Angela. Those cookies look awesome. I have a question for you about Green Monsters. I have finally gotten hooked on Green Monsters, so much that I drink one EVERY day. I love them!!! I put 2 huge handfuls of spinach in with some other ingredients. What I am wondering is if you can eat(drink) too much spinach. I have read conflicting things about the absorption of Iron and Calcium when too much spinach is consumed. What do you know about this and what do you think. I feel like my skin is so much softer and less dry. My hair and nails have improved. My energy is up. These things are amazing. I just want to make sure they are ok to drink daily.
Thanks for introducing me to these and all the great recipes you blog about .
:)

Reply

39 Angela (Oh She Glows) September 2, 2010

I have read that it is a good idea to mix up and ‘rotate’ your greens. Like any other veggie, this is a good idea. I try to mix up the greens in my smoothies whenever I can…sometimes I use kale, spinach, chard (ew), or other random greens I find in my CSA. I think it is always a good idea to not reply too heavily on one type of vegetable because that might mean we are missing out on other nutrients. :)

Reply

40 MarathonVal September 2, 2010

Those first two trials look good to me… I made s’mores bars this week, I love that flavor!

Reply

41 Andrea September 2, 2010

Beautiful cookies! I can’t believe you persevered through all the trials, but at least you had some good cookie-fuel for all that time slaving in the kitchen! :)

Reply

42 Gina September 2, 2010

Those look awesome! Thanks for doing all of the trial work for us so we don’t have to ;)

Reply

43 Heather (Heather's Dish) September 2, 2010

i love vegan cookies for the sole fact that i can eat it all before it’s baked. what’s better than that?! besides these cookies anyway :)

Reply

44 Kristy September 2, 2010

Those cookies look amazing!! They def wouldn’t last long in my house! :)

Reply

45 Kristen @ That Hoosier Girl September 2, 2010

I have a feeling I would be pretty happy if my cookies turned out half as good as your “bad” cookies! They all look delish and I’m sure would have no problem being devoured ;)

Reply

46 Gree September 2, 2010

Wow, those look absolutely delicious, I love the addition of the salt!

Reply

47 Allison September 2, 2010

I made peanut butter chocolate chip cookies today too!!!!! But i made mine softer and chewy:):) I definitely whould have given up after 1 or 2 trials lol thats why you have the bakery:):)

Reply

48 Teri [a foodie stays fit] September 2, 2010

oooh, yummy! I can’t believe how little sugar you had to add to them! Impressive!

Reply

49 lindsay (goodiesgalore) September 2, 2010

you are a nut!

Reply

50 Angela (Oh She Glows) September 2, 2010

Why thank you

Reply

51 Liza (Health Nutting) September 2, 2010

Oh my! Those look absolutely ridiculously insanely good!
I have just recently understood how vitally important and amazing sea salt is in sweet baked goods– YUM!

Reply

52 Olya September 2, 2010

Yum! I’m going to make them right now. I find making yummy baking is a great insentive for my hubby to do the housework. Today I asked him if he would like me to bake some cookies and he can vacuum the house. Or I can vacuum… It didn’t take him long to decide ;)))

Reply

53 Gina (@ Looking Forward) September 2, 2010

I totally had a dream last night that I was trying to create a delicious new healthier cookie recipe, but alas…you did it for me!!! Can’t wait to try these out!

Reply

54 Jolene (www.everydayfoodie.ca) September 2, 2010

I am fascinated by how you come up with recipes like this – impressive!!

Reply

55 lisa September 2, 2010

haha I HATE when I try the same recipe over and over with new modifications, with great hopes and then once its bake. disappointement. I mostly feel bad for wasting ingredients, ya know? But…
those look DELICIOUS! I never saw turbinado sugar. looks so tempting to eat as is!! haha :)

Reply

56 Sana September 2, 2010

I feel like you need to be super determined to make magic happen in the kitchen! I would have quit after trial #!!!!

Reply

57 Caitlin (EatFeats) September 2, 2010

Oh my goodness you are a baking phenomenon! Five trials–that is amazing! I admire your patience and creativity!

Reply

58 Candice @ ChiaSeedMe September 2, 2010

These look awesome!

Reply

59 Chelsea at Striking Balance September 2, 2010

Everytime I think you can’t post a better recipe, you come back with more! These look great, and I have almosttt all of the ingredients on hand. Yum!

Reply

60 Kris September 2, 2010

YUM!!! I will make these and freeze them for the boys! :-)

You are so thoughtful!!!

Reply

61 Kendall September 2, 2010

Let me know if your hiring a taste-tester soon. I think I would be perfectly qualified for the job! :)

Reply

62 Erika @ Health and Happiness in LA September 2, 2010

Uhh… I kind of wish I had not read this post. Because now I really, really want cookies.

Reply

63 Annie@stronghealthyfit September 2, 2010

Wow, those look a.mazing. Five trials, that’s dedication!

Reply

64 Jenn (Jenn's Menu and Lifestyle Blog) September 2, 2010

I love all things sweet and salty! Those look scrumptious. :)

Jenn

Reply

65 Stacey@http://stacey-healthylife.blogspot.com/ September 3, 2010

You are crazy lady to bake 5 trials of it. You must freeze the others I’m guessing. They all looked really good to me.

Reply

66 Marina September 3, 2010

I would go crazy with baking so much cookies!
What did you do with the “failed” ones? :)

Reply

67 Neen@Broad Bean to Runner Bean September 3, 2010

awwww bless you! so many attempts! you really are a baking queen!! thanks for sharing the recipe. as with most of your recipes i’ll be adding this to my “to do” list!!

Reply

68 Heidi - Apples Under My Bed September 3, 2010

Hi Angela!
Firstly, I love your gorgeous blog.
Secondly, these cookies look amazing! Just what I have been after. Here in Australia we don’t often combine peanut butter & chocolate, not to the same extent as it is revered in the US. I love it though – the sweet/salty flavour combination, just beautiful! :)
Heidi xo

Reply

69 Olya September 3, 2010

Hi again! I came to complain. I made this cookies 2 hours ago and… they lasted about 10 min (My hubby had 6!! of them). And then he said that it’s not enough and I have to make them again.. right now!

Angela, because you make such a beautiful food I’ve got to work harder in the kitchen ;))) Thank you very much for all your hard work and wonderful recipes.

Reply

70 Lisa September 3, 2010

I would eat every single one of those cookies! Looks delicious! I love the salty and sweet combination!

Reply

71 Kristy September 3, 2010

Okay – those smores cookies things are clearly the way to my heart :-) and yes yes yes! Finally a fellow slightly salted chocolate chip cookie supporter!

Reply

72 Halley September 3, 2010

5 batches of cookies?! That takes devotion and will power!! Glad you finally nailed your recipe, but if I were you I would have settled with #2 or #3 for sanity sake.

Reply

73 Jillian@ ReshapeYourLife September 3, 2010

All of those look delicious! I really want to try a vegan baking recipe and see if the boy notices a difference… He’s such a skeptic about stuff like that.

I have already switched to earth balance and he doesn’t know the difference! Maybe I should try cookies next?

Reply

74 Chelsea @ One Healthy Munchkin September 3, 2010

I wish I had your patience in the kitchen! 5 trials of cookies must have taken forever! At least the outcome looks amazing though. :D

Reply

75 Gabriela @ Une Vie Saine September 3, 2010

Already bookmarked. Always on the lookout for a fun new vegan cookie recipe!! By the way, I just got caught up on your old posts and loved the scrapbook idea…so sweet! Happy Friday!!

Reply

76 Wanda September 3, 2010

I love your blog. I have a real sweet tooth but I eat healthy. When I need something sweet I always go to your recipes. Thanks so much.

Reply

77 Laura (spokesnoats) September 3, 2010

Wow, that is some serious determination! I give you super props :)

Reply

78 Fallon September 3, 2010

Oh yum!!! Barney butter would be amazing in these cookies.

Reply

79 Fanta September 3, 2010

Is it possible to substitute organic sugar or tubinado with sucanat? Or are they the same thing? :S

Signed – New to baking he he

Reply

80 Lauren @ 40Apples September 3, 2010

Great cookie post!! A.) it’s about cookies, and B.) it’s honestly fascinating to see how a REAL baker tests ingredients and develops a recipe! Your final product looks incredible. Although I’m sure I would’ve loved trials 1 – 4 too! :)

Reply

81 Corey @ the runner's cookie September 3, 2010

Wow, Angela you have so much patience and have the baking skills I wish I had!! The cookies look awesome. Every trial means something learned, right?

Reply

82 Jen September 3, 2010

These look amazing. Could you substitute another flour that is gluten free? I can’t have spelt….?

Reply

83 Amber K September 3, 2010

Those all look great!

Reply

84 Kaitlin With Honey September 3, 2010

The final result looks SO good. Sooooo good!

Reply

85 sassy molassy September 3, 2010

Ooh, this recipe looks amazing. I recently made some far too fluffy cookies. Next time, less flour!

Reply

86 gia September 4, 2010

The s’more chocolate chip cookies look delicious and the thick chocolate chip cookies look very tasty. :)

Reply

87 AGS September 4, 2010

I am very impressed with your tenacity. I would have given up at batch 1. . . Dan is one lucky guy.

Reply

88 Julie @SavvyEats September 4, 2010

Just made these. SO GOOD.

Reply

89 Angela (Oh She Glows) September 4, 2010

Glad you like them!!

Reply

90 Brooke September 25, 2010

I have made those cookies three times in the past two weeks! My husband and I are addicted. Last time I put in some chia seeds and forgot to add the chocolate chips- they still turned out!

Reply

91 Nasim October 5, 2010

Yum! Yum! and Yum! Just made these and already devoured 3 of them! I believe these will fuel me for my run today!

Reply

92 Robyn October 7, 2010

I made a batch of these cookies yesterday for my healthy-food-opposed boyfriend and he decided these are the best cookies ever! I of course didnt tell him they were vegan until after he professed his love. I only hope due to sucessful recipes like these he will keep trying these healthier foods.

And yes I know cookies aren’t really “health foods” but trust me, for this guy, it’s a start!!

Again thanks for sharing these amazing recipes. I haven’t made one I haven’t liked!

Reply

93 mountain girl October 16, 2010

Wow, you are not kidding, are you? That’s tenacity! Thanks for sticking this recipe out…so we can all enjoy it! Looks great!

Reply

94 Laura October 23, 2010

I just made these, wow, yum, thank you :)

Reply

95 Cathy @ What Would Cathy Eat? July 28, 2012

Hi Angela. I’m very late to the party here, but just wondering if you’ve tried them with other flours. I don’t have spelt but am thinking of running out for some. I definitely want the crisp factor, and have been frustrated with soft vegan cookies lately. Thanks!

Reply

96 Analuna April 11, 2014

These were AMAZING! I made them with coconut oil instead of canola and they turned out great. I also doubled the batch but only got about 20 cookies out of it. I think I made them too big- I didn’t realize they would spread so much! They were a huge hit though and people didn’t even realize they were whole grain or vegan! Thanks for all the fabulous recipes.

Reply

97 elizabeth May 31, 2014

i love your blog! and i have a question – i tried making these cookies twice…both results taste good, but the cookies don’t really melt in the oven – they stay in pretty much the same shape they were when i first mold them. since you tried several times to make the perfect cookie i don’t want to stray too far from the measure on any of your ingredients. do you have any suggestions?

Reply

98 Angela (Oh She Glows) June 2, 2014

Hey Elizabeth,
usually when cookies don’t spread out it’s a result of too much flour or not enough liquid. You could try decreasing the flour by a couple tablespoons and see if that helps? I’ll have to revisit the recipe again as it’s been a while! Thanks for trying them out.

Reply

99 Selayna January 19, 2015

I’ve been desperate for good vegan chocolate chip cookies, and these were phenomenal! My dough was a bit too dry/crumbly for the cookies to hold their shape, so I added one tablespoon of Almond Milk, and they turned out perfectly :) Thank you for sharing this recipe.

Reply

100 Britta March 14, 2015

I tried to make these cookies today but somehow the dough remained crumbly even though I added more of the liquid ingredients. I managed to form balls but they did not spread at all in the oven. Do you have an idea what went wrong?

Reply

101 Eris May 28, 2015

Hey Angela, i pretty much tried most deserts on your website, this one didnt turn out well. my favourate is toffee bar. my cookie didnt flatten at all. they stay in ball shape. the only change i made was using coconut oil instead canola oil. any reason?

Reply

102 Mary January 12, 2016

First of all, I am not a vegan by any means. I came across this recipe and thought I’d give it a shot. I had to make a couple minor changes based on what I had on hand (sub spelt for 1 cup all purpose + 1/4 cup whole wheat, and reg semi-sweet choc chips). I didn’t think the cookie was going to hold up as the batter was pretty crumbly. They also didn’t spread out when they cooked for me. But they did stay together, and I gotta say…I was blown away! These were delicious! Definately making these again! Thanks for the great recipe!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: