PB, J, & Chocolate Love Pie



Anyone catch Ellen on Idol last night? Love her :)

We are in the middle of a snow storm so last night was the perfect time to bake!

 IMG 0677 thumb   PB, J, & Chocolate Love Pie

PB, J & Chocolate Love Pie

This is an adaptation of the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, which were adapted from The Kind Diet. I had a hard time cutting this pie without the chocolate cracking and the pie sticking to the pan, so I would probably stick to the cups in the future. This was still fun though and the added strawberry jam was a nice addition.


  • 1/2 cup butter or margarine (I used vegan margarine)
  • 3/4 cup crunchy peanut butter (preferably unsalted)
  • 3/4 cup graham cracker crumbs or 10 graham cracker squares
  • 1/4 cup sugar (I used organic cane sugar)
  • 1 cup chocolate chips (I used vegan dark chocolate chips)
  • 1/4 cup milk (I used almond, unsweetened)
  • Strawberry jam (optional)
  • 4-5 T chopped peanuts, for garnish (optional)

Directions: Grease an 8 inch pie pan. Melt the vegan margarine/butter in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Stir in the peanut butter, graham cracker crumbs, and sugar and mix well. Remove the mixture from the heat. Pour the mixture into the pie pan. Drop strawberry jam over top (see picture below). Combine the chocolate and milk in another pan. Stir over medium heat until the chocolate has melted. Spoon the chocolate evenly over top of the PB & J mixture. Top with chopped peanuts. Place in the freezer for 60-75 minutes until firm. Serve at room temperature.

After pouring the PB mixture into the pie pan and dropping strawberry jam over top:

IMG 0663 thumb   PB, J, & Chocolate Love Pie

With the chocolate layer spread over top:

IMG 0670 thumb   PB, J, & Chocolate Love Pie

Garnish with PEANUTS!!!!!!

IMG 0676 thumb   PB, J, & Chocolate Love Pie  

Just before popping into the FREEZER:

IMG 0674 thumb   PB, J, & Chocolate Love Pie

Tip: Soak the pots and utensils in very hot soapy water while the pie is setting in the freezer. Then when you come back to the kitchen the clean up is very easy and it slides right off.

After about an hour, this bad boy was set. The only problem I had with this pie is that when I cut it, the chocolate cracked and the pie stuck to the pan. I am going to stick to making the cups as they were much easier to remove.

IMG 0682 thumb   PB, J, & Chocolate Love Pie

If you don’t mind a ‘messy’ looking pie then you probably would be fine with this method. It would be great with a scoop of Gena’s Banana Soft Serve…with a twist!

I don’t think I need to say that it tasted delicious!! :mrgreen:


I’m off for my scheduled run!

Enjoy your hump-day…humpity-hump, hump.

Angela Signature thumb13   PB, J, & Chocolate Love Pie

The best index to a person’s character is
a) how he treats people who can’t do him any good and
b) how he treats people who can’t fight back.
~ Abigail Van Buren ~

Let's get social! Follow Angela on Instagram (@ohsheglows + @theglowspot), Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and Google+

Previous Posts

{ 70 comments… read them below or add one }

Jessica @ How Sweet It Is February 10, 2010

Oh goodness does that look DELICIOUS!! You come up with the best treats ever. I want to eat that thru the screen, girl!!


angela @ a healthy fit February 10, 2010

oh my, that looks amazing!!! It is not even 9am and I want to eat that…like now!


Christina February 10, 2010

Oh Yum! That looks great =) Anything that involves peanut butter and chocolate has to be good.


Anna @ Newlywed, Newly Veg February 10, 2010

YUM!!! I never mind a messy dessert as long as it tastes good…and this one definitely looks like it tastes GREAT!!!

Angela, a while back you featured your friend’s business that had a lot of really cute baby stuff on it– what is the name of the website, if you don’t mind me asking? My sister is expecting in March, and I remmeber the stuff on that site being really cute and special! Thank you!!


Angela (Oh She Glows) February 10, 2010

http://www.babyenchanted.com/ :) Its a great website!


Bree February 10, 2010

Thanks Ange! Also, if she’s having a girl, we just launched a 2nd site for baby and toddler girls:




Sarah February 10, 2010

Oh YUM! I know what flavor my after-Zumba smoothie is gonna be… PB & Chocolate!


Katie February 10, 2010

I am a huge Ellen fan as well. She was great last night :)


Jessica @ The Process of Healing February 10, 2010

Oh gosh… that sounds amazing!!! I love PB & J and then add chocolate to it… amazing! You are SO creative! Can I borrow your brain? ;)


Wendy February 10, 2010

Love Ellen, and that pie lookes wicked! Gonna have to whip one up really soon!


Lauren @ Eater not a runner February 10, 2010

That looks delicious to me! And I love Ellen too :-)


Heather @ Side of Sneakers February 10, 2010

mmm how interesting!!! :)


Amy February 10, 2010

Is it just me, or did Ellen get super hot suddenly?

I don’t watch her show often, but last week I watched a few times and I couldn’t get over how beautiful she looked!

Thought the same when watching Idol last night. I think she’ll be a great addition to the team of judges. :)


Angela (Oh She Glows) February 10, 2010

I said the same thing to Eric…she looked the best Ive ver seen her!!!!


Tiffany @ A Dantat's Life February 10, 2010

ahhh that is so drool worthy, and totally perfect for valentine’s day! i didn’t catch ellen on idol last night (was watching biggest loser), but i love her talk show! she’s hilarious :D


Teri [a foodie stays fit] February 10, 2010

Yes, Ellen was awesome! I think she is a great addition to the show. I love her.

And that pie looks sooooo good!


Kerri February 10, 2010

Omggggggggg my mouth is watering that looks so delicious!!! I would have no restraint…I’d literally eat the entire thing in one sitting!


Ameena February 10, 2010

Perfect for Valetine’s Day! Is it weird that I could eat that right now and it isn’t even 6:30am? I haven’t even had breakfast yet!!

I really liked Ellen’s addition to the show. I will miss Simon next year for sure though.


Estela @ Weekly Bite February 10, 2010

Oh my! This looks incredible!!!!


Erin (Travel, Eat, Repeat) February 10, 2010

Who cares what it looks like as long as it tastes good?! Yum! :D


Kt F @ Through The Finish February 10, 2010

Oh my GOODNESS that looks delicious! And it looks super-simple! I think I might be making it for my friends soon… Thanks for the recipe!


christie, honoring health February 10, 2010

That looks delicious!!


Allie (Live Laugh Eat) February 10, 2010

I love that you bake after HOURS of baking Glo Bars :) I would too!


Amy @ Everything is Homemade February 10, 2010

Hi – I just found your blog this week! I’ve made the PB cups before from The Kind Diet and they are excellent. I made them as minis for the holidays. My entire family gobbled them up and no one knew they were vegan (or even thought to ask). Great idea to turn it into a pie. I might have to try that despite the chocolate issues.

I loved Ellen on Idol last night. I thought she was a great addition.


Brittany February 10, 2010

Love Pie sounds delicious and perfect for V-day!


Ann February 10, 2010

Hi Angela! I read all the time, but this is my first comment – I think you are wonderful! I made the peanut butter cups a few weeks ago and used mini muffin pans. I sprayed the pans and didn’t use liners and it was a nightmare to get them out! Probably much like you experienced with the pie. I’m going to use liners going forward for the cups (they were delicious, but too ugly to give away after I chipped them from the pan -haha). A circle of parchment in the bottom of the pie plan might help prevent sticking.


Orla February 10, 2010

Looks great. A tip for stopping the chocolate cracking is to pour boiling water into a jug that will hold the entire length of the knife that you are using to cut the pie. Make sure that your knife also has a sharp tip. Let the knife heat up a little and then slowly cut the pie. For each new cut into the pie you make, soak the knife for a couple seconds and wipe clean with some tissue. Usually works for me. Hope it works!.


Run Sarah February 10, 2010

That looks amazing Ang! Thanks for the recipe!


Jenn @ Livewellfit February 10, 2010

You are my love Ange…I love love love anything peanut butter and that just looks to do for! :)

We are getting a ton of snow here as well in Boston so baking is the perfect thing to do.


Lindsay Perrone (goodiesgalore) February 10, 2010

Drooling. I certainly don’t mind THAT messy pie. Yum


Shannon (The Daily Balance) February 10, 2010

this look amazing! it wouldn’t matter if the pie stuck to the pan when slicing it — i’ll be eating it all in one sitting ;)


Ally (Exercise and Pies) February 10, 2010

aww thats caaaute! and it adds yet another reason I hate my nut allergy


Lauren February 10, 2010

This looks absolutely amazing! Messy food is always the best.


Heather (Heather's Dish) February 10, 2010

that looks so incredible…like a massive healthier version of a reese’s cup :)


Tasha - The Clean Eating Mama February 10, 2010

Incredible! It looks so mouth watering!


Joelle (The Pancake Girl) February 10, 2010

Mmm that looks good! I’m about to bake too- blizzard over here in D.C.!


Katie February 10, 2010

I think Ellen looked amazing because she’s loving being VEGAN! :) And she has her own chef…

I love your blog. Keep those amazing recipes coming! I made your Spelt burgers the other night and my husband won’t stop eating them!!

Have a great run today!


*Andrea* February 10, 2010

LOOKS AMAZING!!!!!! didn’t see idol, but i LOVE ellen. she’s such a great person and beautiful inside and out.

have a great run and day :)


Heidi February 10, 2010

Ahhhh. This is genius! Genius! Absolutley genius. I want to reach right into my screen and take a bite!!!

I saw Ellen on Idol last night, that woman is absolutely hilarious. Should be a great addition to the show! I’m excited to see more of her


Beth @ DiningAndDishing February 10, 2010

Angela, that pie looks seriously amazing!!! I would fly to Canada for a slice :)


Katie February 10, 2010

…and now I know exactly what to make my husband for Valentine’s Day! He loves peanut butter and he loves pie. Perfect!


Annie February 10, 2010

Hi Angela.. I’ve been reading you blog for a few months now but this is actually my first comment! I just wanted to give you a tip for your pie (that looks so delish! I love that recipe from Alicia’s book and made those around Halloween). Try using a tart pan! I have a similar dessert where I had a nut based crust and chocolate filling and I couldn’t imagine trying to get pieces out of a regular pie pan without it being a complete disaster. Hopefully this solves your issue with the pie!! Here is the link for the flourless chocolate tart that I made =]
Have a great day!! – Annie


Danielle (Coffee Run) February 10, 2010

Omg your pie looks amazing :D I know what you mean about the cold weather and wanting to bake!


Page 1 of 212»

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: