• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Oh She Glows
Menu
  • Recipe Search
  • Cookbook Recipes
  • Recipe Categories
  • App
  • My Cookbooks
  • About
    • Close
Home » Recipes » Anything and Everything

The Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie That Never Was

October 6, 2011

IMG_2268

You know, I think Pumpkin Pies are totally overrated.

Pumpkin, sugar, and a buttery crust? Meh.

Over it. Pumpkin Pie is so 1651.

But clearly you wouldn’t believe such a tall tale. You know me better than that…don’t you. You know the truth is that I desperately wanted to make a vegan and soy-free pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving this weekend. I wanted to make it for you, so you could make it for your families.

…and maybe send me one in the mail.

Well, it bombed. And I don’t mean, “It fell apart, but still tasted amazing!”, but “it fell apart and tasted like it had been sitting on the counter since Thanksgiving 1987.”

For real.

Remember my beloved Double chocolate torte that hides avocados so well? That was a good idea.

Pumpkin Pie Cinnamon Rolls? Excellent idea.

Avocados in a pumpkin pie filling? Bad idea. Baaaaaad idea.

IMG_2584

Have you ever tasted avocados after they’ve been cooked in the oven? They are bitter…and musky. Two excellent qualities for a pumpkin pie.

Not.

In this sad moment, I remembered the Pumpkin Brownie Pie I made last year adapted from Isa’s recipe.

20101002IMG_4091

Chocolate brownie, pumpkin pie filling, with a sweet pecan topping?

20101002IMG_3991

Great idea.

20101002IMG_4025

Somehow, I don’t think my family will mind me making this two years in a row.

20101002IMG_4102

If I recall, it was the talk of the table last year. The Pumpkin Gingerbread with Spiced Buttercream did pretty well for itself too. You can find the recipes in this PDF.

20101002IMG_8854

I just hope they aren’t expecting a Luxury Dinner Party. That’s where I draw the line.

As for that pumpkin pie, I guess there’s always hope for the American Thanksgiving. Perhaps, I shouldn’t give up just yet…

~~~

And now from a failed recipe to blog awards. I have stellar timing, don’t I? ;)

 

n-bestoverall n-bestvegblog

A big thank you to everyone who nominated me for a Foodbuzz award!! I found out yesterday that I was nominated for two categories:

  • Best Overall Blog
  • Best Veg Blog

 

I would greatly appreciate your vote(s) of support, but if you don’t vote for me there are a ton of amazing bloggers all worthy in their categories. I’m so happy to see many friends on the list!

You can vote here!

Now I’m off to rock the vote…literally, at the polls.

I’ll return with a kick butt recipe. Mark my words.

More Anything and Everything

  • Sun-Kissed Pasta Salad, Busy Bee Salad, and Vanilla Buttermilk Loaf Cake with Berries and Cream
    Spring Celebration Menu for Mother’s Day or any occasion
  • My new cookbook, Oh She Glows Salads, is here!
  • Zesty Lemon, Dill, and Oregano Dressing
  • Picture of Roasted Pumpkin Seeds
    How To Roast Perfect Pumpkin Seeds – Easy, Crunchy, Addictive!

Filed Under: Anything and Everything

Subscribe
Notify of
Check this box so that we can filter out the questions and respond to you quicker.
Recipe Rating
Made this recipe? Leave a review.

144 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mac
14 years ago

Mmm looks good! Congrats on the nomination!

Reply
Isobelle
14 years ago

Oh, man! This looks too good to be true. I have been staring at a cupboard full of pumpkin for the past two weeks and have been making excuses not to use it, mainly because I have just been waiting for the right recipe to come along.
Now, bingo! Here it is. Thanks a bunch :)

Reply
Jeanette
14 years ago

If you are even still reading this comments (because wow you have alot!) I have a great vegan, soy free one it uses coconut milk. I can dredge up the recipe if you want but the basics are sugar, pumpkin coconut milk and the crust uses palm fruit shortening. Good luck

Reply
Angela Liddon (Oh She Glows)
Author
Reply to  Jeanette
14 years ago

That sounds tasty! :)

Reply
Jolene (www.everydayfoodie.ca)
14 years ago

That pumpkin gingerbread with spiced butter cream is still one of the best tasting foods I have ever had the pleasure of eating. I have made it so many times, and can’t wait to make it again very soon.

Reply
Kelsey
14 years ago

I like that you blog about both success and failure ;)

Reply
Alexandra
14 years ago

Hey Angela! I make your pumpkin pie brownie cupcakes and they are absolutely amazing. Fun fact: I just finished eating one now and am still savouring the moment… mmmmm. Thank you for all your inspiring & delicious posts! :)

Reply
Angela Liddon (Oh She Glows)
Author
Reply to  Alexandra
14 years ago

Glad you enjoyed them Alexandra! :) Wish I had one too… ;)

Reply
Jenn
14 years ago

I’ve had luck blending cashews with pumpkin, sweetener, spices and thickener for a delicious, rich, vegan and soy free pumpkin pie.

Reply
Angela Liddon (Oh She Glows)
Author
Reply to  Jenn
14 years ago

That sounds great :)

Reply
Celena
14 years ago

I just found your site and OH MY GOODNESS, I’m in love. We have very similar tastes and ideas, methinks, and I’m super excited to start following you in your culinary adventures. That said, I too am on a search to make a delicious vegan pumpkin pie with NO TOFU! Le sigh… I made about 3 or 4 versions last November (to the amusement of my boyfriend). A couple came close, but I’m a perfectionist. I am setting out to try some new things this year and hope for better results. If they don’t turn out, though, or perhaps even if they do, that chocolate pumpkin brownie pie IS happening! As is the pumpkin gingerbread. Thank you! And Congrats on your nominations! :))

Reply
Jennifer
10 years ago

Hi
I can’t seem to find your pumpkin brownie pie anywhere. Can you help me get a hold of it?

Thanks!

Reply
« Previous 1 … 4 5 6

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

About Angela

I’m Angela, the founder of Oh She Glows. Since 2008, I’ve been on a journey to glow from the inside out by creating crowd-pleasing plant-based recipes. I’m a New York Times Bestselling cookbook author and award-winning app creator. Click below for my full story!
Read More

Pre-Order Oh She Glows Salads

Trending Now

  • Black Bean and Butternut Squash Burritos
  • Glowing Spiced Lentil Soup

Footer

Oh She Glows

  • My Story
  • The App
  • My Cookbooks
  • OSG in the Media
  • Archives

Popular

  • Recipe Search
  • Recipe Index
  • Cookbook Index
  • My Favourite Skin Care Products
  • My Most-Used Kitchen Tools

Follow on Social Media

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2026 Oh She Glows. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
Want to see more Oh She Glows recipes in your Google results? Click here to add us as a preferred source.

An Elite CafeMedia Food Publisher

Oh She Glows Salads, is here!

Inside my latest cookbook, you’ll find crowd-pleasing plant-based salads, satisfying toppers, bold flavour boosters, and vibrant dressings that will completely change how
you see salads.

Plus…

  • Make-ahead tips and shortcuts
  • Storage and reheating guidance
  • Seasonal salad chapters
  • A delectable plant-based dessert chapter
  • Over 100 full-colour photographs
  • How to craft irresistible salad dressings
Purchase Oh She Glows Salads from Amazon
Purchase Oh She Glows Salads from Barnes & Noble